Payment overview · 2025
General Payments
$3,369.45
158 reported records · 28 companies
Healthcare provider profile · identity verified
Philip W Chung, M.D.
Allopathic & Osteopathic Physicians|Internal Medicine|Nephrology · TORRANCE, CA · NPI 1003881889
Verified facts
What the public records show
CMS Open Payments records show Philip W Chung, M.D. received $3,369.45 in general payments during 2025 across 158 reported records.
Travere Therapeutics, Inc. accounted for 10.3% of that reported general-payment amount.
The Open Payments records used for this analysis explicitly named 31 associated products.
A separate comparison found the same explicitly named product in public Medicare Part D data: Farxiga, Jardiance, Kerendia, Velphoro, Veltassa.
AKEBIA THERAPEUTICS INC reported payments to this doctor in 2025. Across the 2025 Open Payments General Payment records loaded for this analysis, that same reporting entity reported Auryxia as an associated drug or biological on 494 records involving 327 distinct recipient NPIs. Public Medicare Part D data also shows 21 claims for Auryxia by this doctor in 2024.
AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP reported payments to this doctor in 2025. Across the 2025 Open Payments General Payment records loaded for this analysis, that same reporting entity reported FARXIGA as an associated drug or biological on 106133 records involving 42906 distinct recipient NPIs. Public Medicare Part D data also shows 325 claims for Farxiga by this doctor in 2024.
AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP reported payments to this doctor in 2025. Across the 2025 Open Payments General Payment records loaded for this analysis, that same reporting entity reported LOKELMA as an associated drug or biological on 6897 records involving 4326 distinct recipient NPIs. Public Medicare Part D data also shows 31 claims for Lokelma by this doctor in 2024.
Bayer Healthcare Pharmaceuticals Inc. reported payments to this doctor in 2025. Across the 2025 Open Payments General Payment records loaded for this analysis, that same reporting entity reported Kerendia as an associated drug or biological on 138674 records involving 48458 distinct recipient NPIs. Public Medicare Part D data also shows 37 claims for Kerendia by this doctor in 2024.
Boehringer Ingelheim Pharmaceuticals, Inc. reported payments to this doctor in 2025. Across the 2025 Open Payments General Payment records loaded for this analysis, that same reporting entity reported JARDIANCE as an associated drug or biological on 123636 records involving 49438 distinct recipient NPIs. Public Medicare Part D data also shows 148 claims for Jardiance by this doctor in 2024.
Fresenius USA Marketing, Inc. reported payments to this doctor in 2025. Across the 2025 Open Payments General Payment records loaded for this analysis, that same reporting entity reported VELPHORO as an associated drug or biological on 8763 records involving 2642 distinct recipient NPIs. Public Medicare Part D data also shows 13 claims for Velphoro by this doctor in 2024.
Lilly USA, LLC reported payments to this doctor in 2025. Across the 2025 Open Payments General Payment records loaded for this analysis, that same reporting entity reported JARDIANCE as an associated drug or biological on 47708 records involving 23833 distinct recipient NPIs. Public Medicare Part D data also shows 148 claims for Jardiance by this doctor in 2024.
Vifor Pharma, Inc. reported payments to this doctor in 2025. Across the 2025 Open Payments General Payment records loaded for this analysis, that same reporting entity reported Veltassa as an associated drug or biological on 5970 records involving 2480 distinct recipient NPIs. Public Medicare Part D data also shows 110 claims for Veltassa by this doctor in 2024.
These records do not establish that a payment influenced prescribing or medical care.
Separate record types
Research & Ownership
Research Payments (direct recipient): not present in the loaded data
Associated Research Funding (for example, named PI): not present in the loaded data
Ownership / Investment: not present in the loaded data
These categories are never added into the General Payments headline. Associated research funding must not be described as money the doctor personally received unless the source record supports that conclusion.
Who paid this doctor?
Companies in 2025 General Payments
| Reported company | Canonical company | Amount | Share | Records | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Travere Therapeutics, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $348.79 | 10.3% | 25 | 2025 |
| AKEBIA THERAPEUTICS INC | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $307.04 | 9.1% | 12 | 2025 |
| Otsuka America Pharmaceutical, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $272.87 | 8.1% | 10 | 2025 |
| Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $224.36 | 6.7% | 13 | 2025 |
| Ardelyx, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $215.97 | 6.4% | 10 | 2025 |
| Bayer Healthcare Pharmaceuticals Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $202.13 | 6.0% | 10 | 2025 |
| Calliditas Therapeutics US Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $187.44 | 5.6% | 8 | 2025 |
| AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $155.91 | 4.6% | 8 | 2025 |
| ANI Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $139.72 | 4.2% | 5 | 2025 |
| Amgen Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $125.14 | 3.7% | 6 | 2025 |
| SCPHARMACEUTICALS INC. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $121.43 | 3.6% | 5 | 2025 |
| Boehringer Ingelheim Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $107.13 | 3.2% | 5 | 2025 |
| Novo Nordisk Inc | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $100.67 | 3.0% | 5 | 2025 |
| Mallinckrodt Hospital Products Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $98.72 | 2.9% | 4 | 2025 |
| Lilly USA, LLC | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $87.22 | 2.6% | 5 | 2025 |
| Janssen Biotech, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $84.40 | 2.5% | 3 | 2025 |
| Vifor Pharma, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $80.49 | 2.4% | 3 | 2025 |
| Apellis Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $74.04 | 2.2% | 3 | 2025 |
| GlaxoSmithKline, LLC. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $72.48 | 2.1% | 3 | 2025 |
| Aurinia Pharma U.S., Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $71.04 | 2.1% | 3 | 2025 |
| OPKO Pharmaceuticals, LLC | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $63.61 | 1.9% | 3 | 2025 |
| ABIOMED | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $56.46 | 1.7% | 2 | 2025 |
| Alexion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $52.20 | 1.6% | 2 | 2025 |
| KYOWA KIRIN, INC. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $29.86 | 0.9% | 1 | 2025 |
| Rigel Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $26.82 | 0.8% | 1 | 2025 |
| Ascendis Pharma Endocrinology Inc | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $25.29 | 0.8% | 1 | 2025 |
| GENZYME CORPORATION | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $23.30 | 0.7% | 1 | 2025 |
| Fresenius USA Marketing, Inc. | Unresolved — no canonical attribution shown | $14.92 | 0.4% | 1 | 2025 |
What were the payments for?
Payment categories
| Category | Amount | Records |
|---|---|---|
| Food and Beverage | $3,369.45 | 158 |
A meal, consulting fee, royalty, and travel payment describe different kinds of reported relationships and should not be interpreted as equivalent.
Analysis 1 · Payment-linked products
Products named in Open Payments records
| Reported product | Type | Reported company | Related amount* | Records | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vafseo Normalized: vafseo |
Drug | AKEBIA THERAPEUTICS INC | $307.04 | 12 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| JYNARQUE Normalized: jynarque |
Drug | Otsuka America Pharmaceutical, Inc. | $241.08 | 9 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| IBSRELA Normalized: ibsrela |
Drug | Ardelyx, Inc. | $215.97 | 10 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| Kerendia Normalized: kerendia |
Drug | Bayer Healthcare Pharmaceuticals Inc. | $202.13 | 10 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| JARDIANCE Normalized: jardiance |
Drug | Boehringer Ingelheim Pharmaceuticals, Inc., Lilly USA, LLC | $194.35 | 10 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| TARPEYO Normalized: tarpeyo |
Drug | Calliditas Therapeutics US Inc. | $187.44 | 8 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| FARXIGA Normalized: farxiga |
Drug | AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP | $155.91 | 8 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| PURIFIED CORTROPHIN GEL Normalized: purified cortrophin gel |
Drug | ANI Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | $139.72 | 5 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| KRYSTEXXA Normalized: krystexxa |
Biological | Amgen Inc. | $125.14 | 6 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| FUROSCIX Normalized: furoscix |
Drug | SCPHARMACEUTICALS INC. | $121.43 | 5 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| ACTHAR Normalized: acthar |
Biological | Mallinckrodt Hospital Products Inc. | $98.72 | 4 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| TREMFYA Normalized: tremfya |
Drug | Janssen Biotech, Inc. | $84.40 | 3 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| Veltassa Normalized: veltassa |
Drug | Vifor Pharma, Inc. | $80.49 | 3 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| Empaveli Normalized: empaveli |
Drug | Apellis Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | $74.04 | 3 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| LUPKYNIS Normalized: lupkynis |
Drug | Aurinia Pharma U.S., Inc. | $71.04 | 3 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| RAYALDEE Normalized: rayaldee |
Drug | OPKO Pharmaceuticals, LLC | $63.61 | 3 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| Ozempic Normalized: ozempic |
Drug | Novo Nordisk Inc | $62.06 | 3 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| ULTOMIRIS Normalized: ultomiris |
Biological | Alexion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | $52.20 | 2 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| BENLYSTA Normalized: benlysta |
Biological | GlaxoSmithKline, LLC. | $51.47 | 2 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| Fabhalta Normalized: fabhalta |
Drug | Novartis Pharmaceuticals Corporation | $32.73 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| VOYXACT Normalized: voyxact |
Drug | Otsuka America Pharmaceutical, Inc. | $31.79 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| CRYSVITA Normalized: crysvita |
Drug | KYOWA KIRIN, INC. | $29.86 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| Gavreto Normalized: gavreto |
Drug | Rigel Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | $26.82 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| Rezlidhia Normalized: rezlidhia |
Drug | Rigel Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | $26.82 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| TAVALISSE Normalized: tavalisse |
Drug | Rigel Pharmaceuticals, Inc. | $26.82 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| Yorvipath Normalized: yorvipath |
Drug | Ascendis Pharma Endocrinology Inc | $25.29 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| FABRAZYME Normalized: fabrazyme |
Biological | GENZYME CORPORATION | $23.30 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| AREXVY Normalized: arexvy |
Biological | GlaxoSmithKline, LLC. | $21.01 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| SHINGRIX Normalized: shingrix |
Biological | GlaxoSmithKline, LLC. | $21.01 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| Wegovy Normalized: wegovy |
Drug | Novo Nordisk Inc | $16.26 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
| VELPHORO Normalized: velphoro |
Drug | Fresenius USA Marketing, Inc. | $14.92 | 1 | 2025 |
Source payment records
|
|||||
* Product-associated amounts are non-additive because one payment record may name more than one product.
These products were named on specific Open Payments records. A named product does not show that the payment influenced treatment or prescribing.
Public prescribing for products named in payments
| Open Payments product | Payment year | Part D brand | Part D year | Claims | Match method | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FARXIGA farxiga |
2025 | Farxiga | 2024 | 325 | exact normalized | Medicare Part D |
| JARDIANCE jardiance |
2025 | Jardiance | 2024 | 148 | exact normalized | Medicare Part D |
| Kerendia kerendia |
2025 | Kerendia | 2024 | 37 Beneficiary count suppressed |
exact normalized | Medicare Part D |
| VELPHORO velphoro |
2025 | Velphoro | 2024 | 13 Beneficiary count suppressed |
exact normalized | Medicare Part D |
| Veltassa veltassa |
2025 | Veltassa | 2024 | 110 | exact normalized | Medicare Part D |
The presence of the same drug in both datasets does not show that a payment caused or influenced a prescription.
Analysis 2 · Same-company prescribing overlap
Drugs reported in other payments from the same company that also appear in Medicare Part D
This analysis is independent from products named on this doctor’s individual payment records. A row appears only when the exact Open Payments reporting entity paid this doctor, that same reporting entity reported the drug or biological on at least 10 loaded General Payment records involving at least 2 distinct recipient NPIs, and this doctor has the same non-generic brand in public Part D data. This does not mean the company owns or manufactures the drug.
| Paying company | Payment year | Drug reported by same entity | Open Payments evidence | Part D | Claims | Beneficiaries |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AKEBIA THERAPEUTICS INC Exact reporting entity; no affiliate inference |
2025 | Auryxia open payments reported associated product |
CMS Open Payments — General Payments 494 supporting records · 327 recipient NPIs · example record 1241812131 |
Auryxia · 2024 Exact normalized brand match · 1 Part D row |
21 | suppressed by CMS |
| AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP Exact reporting entity; no affiliate inference |
2025 | FARXIGA open payments reported associated product |
CMS Open Payments — General Payments 106133 supporting records · 42906 recipient NPIs · example record 1206131362 |
Farxiga · 2024 Exact normalized brand match · 1 Part D row |
325 | 65 |
| AstraZeneca Pharmaceuticals LP Exact reporting entity; no affiliate inference |
2025 | LOKELMA open payments reported associated product |
CMS Open Payments — General Payments 6897 supporting records · 4326 recipient NPIs · example record 1206131624 |
Lokelma · 2024 Exact normalized brand match · 1 Part D row |
31 | 13 |
| Bayer Healthcare Pharmaceuticals Inc. Exact reporting entity; no affiliate inference |
2025 | Kerendia open payments reported associated product |
CMS Open Payments — General Payments 138674 supporting records · 48458 recipient NPIs · example record 1225434663 |
Kerendia · 2024 Exact normalized brand match · 1 Part D row |
37 | suppressed by CMS |
| Boehringer Ingelheim Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Exact reporting entity; no affiliate inference |
2025 | JARDIANCE open payments reported associated product |
CMS Open Payments — General Payments 123636 supporting records · 49438 recipient NPIs · example record 1221811583 |
Jardiance · 2024 Exact normalized brand match · 1 Part D row |
148 | 45 |
| Fresenius USA Marketing, Inc. Exact reporting entity; no affiliate inference |
2025 | VELPHORO open payments reported associated product |
CMS Open Payments — General Payments 8763 supporting records · 2642 recipient NPIs · example record 1244803773 |
Velphoro · 2024 Exact normalized brand match · 1 Part D row |
13 | suppressed by CMS |
| Lilly USA, LLC Exact reporting entity; no affiliate inference |
2025 | JARDIANCE open payments reported associated product |
CMS Open Payments — General Payments 47708 supporting records · 23833 recipient NPIs · example record 1186464557 |
Jardiance · 2024 Exact normalized brand match · 1 Part D row |
148 | 45 |
| Vifor Pharma, Inc. Exact reporting entity; no affiliate inference |
2025 | Veltassa open payments reported associated product |
CMS Open Payments — General Payments 5970 supporting records · 2480 recipient NPIs · example record 1172020739 |
Veltassa · 2024 Exact normalized brand match · 1 Part D row |
110 | 36 |
These facts do not show that a payment was for the drug, that the company owns or manufactures the drug, or that a payment caused or influenced prescribing.
Public Medicare Part D data
Provider-and-drug rows loaded for 2024
| Brand | Generic | Claims | Beneficiaries |
|---|---|---|---|
| Farxiga | Dapagliflozin Propanediol | 325 | 65 |
| Amlodipine Besylate | Amlodipine Besylate | 281 | 91 |
| Losartan Potassium | Losartan Potassium | 262 | 83 |
| Furosemide | Furosemide | 245 | 85 |
| Hydralazine Hcl | Hydralazine Hcl | 158 | 55 |
| Jardiance | Empagliflozin | 148 | 45 |
| Allopurinol | Allopurinol | 135 | 47 |
| Veltassa | Patiromer Calcium Sorbitex | 110 | 36 |
| Sevelamer Carbonate | Sevelamer Carbonate | 96 | 36 |
| Calcitriol | Calcitriol | 81 | 30 |
| Prednisone | Prednisone | 73 | 16 |
| Retacrit | Epoetin Alfa-Epbx | 69 | 30 |
| Atorvastatin Calcium | Atorvastatin Calcium | 67 | 20 |
| Nifedipine Er | Nifedipine | 61 | 20 |
| Hydrochlorothiazide | Hydrochlorothiazide | 60 | 23 |
| Lisinopril | Lisinopril | 57 | 22 |
| Cephalexin | Cephalexin | 50 | 37 |
| Hydroxyzine Hcl | Hydroxyzine Hcl | 48 | suppressed |
| Metoprolol Succinate | Metoprolol Succinate | 48 | suppressed |
| Calcium Acetate | Calcium Acetate | 47 | 15 |
| Potassium Chloride | Potassium Chloride | 47 | 19 |
| Famotidine | Famotidine | 45 | 14 |
| Chlorthalidone | Chlorthalidone | 40 | 17 |
| Insulin Syringe | Syringe And Needle,insulin,1ml | 40 | 16 |
| Metoprolol Tartrate | Metoprolol Tartrate | 40 | 13 |
| Valsartan | Valsartan | 38 | 18 |
| Kerendia | Finerenone | 37 | suppressed |
| Tamsulosin Hcl | Tamsulosin Hcl | 37 | suppressed |
| Midodrine Hcl | Midodrine Hcl | 36 | 14 |
| Clonidine Hcl | Clonidine Hcl | 34 | 14 |
| Omeprazole | Omeprazole | 34 | suppressed |
| Lokelma | Sodium Zirconium Cyclosilicate | 31 | 13 |
| Ondansetron Odt | Ondansetron | 28 | suppressed |
| Febuxostat | Febuxostat | 27 | suppressed |
| Gabapentin | Gabapentin | 24 | 12 |
| Amoxicillin | Amoxicillin | 23 | 16 |
| Irbesartan | Irbesartan | 23 | suppressed |
| Procrit | Epoetin Alfa | 23 | 12 |
| Xphozah | Tenapanor Hcl | 23 | suppressed |
| Olmesartan Medoxomil | Olmesartan Medoxomil | 22 | suppressed |
| Auryxia | Ferric Citrate | 21 | suppressed |
| Lactulose | Lactulose | 20 | suppressed |
| Labetalol Hcl | Labetalol Hcl | 18 | suppressed |
| Lantus Solostar | Insulin Glargine,hum.Rec.Anlog | 17 | suppressed |
| Metformin Hcl | Metformin Hcl | 17 | suppressed |
| Cinacalcet Hcl | Cinacalcet Hcl | 16 | suppressed |
| Gentamicin Sulfate | Gentamicin Sulfate | 16 | suppressed |
| Minoxidil | Minoxidil | 16 | suppressed |
| Mycophenolate Mofetil | Mycophenolate Mofetil | 16 | suppressed |
| Potassium Citrate Er | Potassium Citrate | 16 | suppressed |
| Spironolactone | Spironolactone | 16 | suppressed |
| Benazepril Hcl | Benazepril Hcl | 15 | suppressed |
| Diltiazem 24hr Er | Diltiazem Hcl | 15 | suppressed |
| Carvedilol | Carvedilol | 14 | suppressed |
| Ciprofloxacin Hcl | Ciprofloxacin Hcl | 14 | 13 |
| Clopidogrel | Clopidogrel Bisulfate | 14 | suppressed |
| Eliquis | Apixaban | 14 | suppressed |
| Metformin Hcl Er | Metformin Hcl | 14 | suppressed |
| Novolog Flexpen | Insulin Aspart | 14 | suppressed |
| Vitamin D2 | Ergocalciferol (Vitamin D2) | 14 | suppressed |
| Finasteride | Finasteride | 13 | suppressed |
| Velphoro | Sucroferric Oxyhydroxide | 13 | suppressed |
| Amoxicillin-Clavulanate Potass | Amoxicillin/Potassium Clav | 12 | 12 |
| Colchicine | Colchicine | 12 | suppressed |
| Pantoprazole Sodium | Pantoprazole Sodium | 12 | suppressed |
| Pregabalin | Pregabalin | 12 | suppressed |
Timeline
Payment and prescribing data by year
Open Payments and Medicare Part D may refer to different years. They are shown separately rather than aligned as if they describe the same period.
| Year | General Payments | Main payer | Explicit products | Company overlaps | Part D coverage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $3,369.45 · 158 records | Travere Therapeutics, Inc. | ACTHAR, AREXVY, BENLYSTA, CRYSVITA, Empaveli, FABRAZYME, FARXIGA, FUROSCIX, Fabhalta, Gavreto, IBSRELA, JARDIANCE, JYNARQUE, KRYSTEXXA, Kerendia, LUPKYNIS, Ozempic, PURIFIED CORTROPHIN GEL, RAYALDEE, Rezlidhia, SHINGRIX, TARPEYO, TAVALISSE, TREMFYA, ULTOMIRIS, VELPHORO, VOYXACT, Vafseo, Veltassa, Wegovy, Yorvipath | 8 | — |
| 2024 | — | — | — | — | Complete |
Questions to ask
Questions you could discuss with your doctor
- What role, if any, does Farxiga play in your treatment recommendations for me?
- How do you evaluate evidence when you have a financial relationship with AKEBIA THERAPEUTICS INC?
- Are there reasonable alternatives I should understand when we discuss treatment options?
- How should I interpret the industry-payment records shown here in the context of my care?
These are general questions generated from reviewed templates. They are not personalized medical advice.
Sources and limitations
How to read this page
- Payment and Medicare prescribing data can cover different years; every comparison shows both years explicitly.
- Part D does not represent a doctor’s entire practice; it excludes many patients and is subject to CMS public-release thresholds.
- Company–drug relationships must have an auditable source, a precise relationship type, and a valid evidence period. Unresolved mappings are not published.
- Generic drug claims are not attributed to a specific manufacturer without manufacturer-level evidence.
- When a source extract is incomplete, missing rows are never treated as proof of no payments or no prescriptions.
Loaded source releases
| Dataset | Year | Publication | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| CMS Open Payments — General Payments | 2025 | 2026-06-30 | Original source |
| Medicare Part D Prescribers by Provider and Drug | 2024 | 2026-05-06 | Original source |
| NPPES Data Dissemination V2 | current / reference data | 2026-08-10 | Original source |
Full methodology · Questions & answers · Report a possible error